Episode 55: Two Shades of Guilty

Roger and Sam_shades of guilty_opening GIF_ep55

Roger Collins is living on lies. To everyone he knows, he must remain a stranger. Yet with every passing day his veneer is being chipped away little by little, largely through the perceptive and watchful gaze of his sister Elizabeth, who but for the good of David would have little if any use for the thoughtless extravagance of her brother’s ways. If you think about it, since his return to the ancestral mansion around a month ago, Roger has brought nothing but trouble not only for the family name, but also to those even loosely associated with Collinwood and all it represents.

If only Roger had stayed away in Augusta, Burke Devlin would never have returned to Collinsport to set in motion a plot to ruin the Collins family, given how despite that he blames Collins money and prestige for railroading him into prison, his principal nemesis had been mainly Roger, with his testimony on the witness stand having sealed Devlin’s fate.

So Roger schemed his way back into Collinwood, using as his bargaining chip the welfare of David’s future: “Roger made an unexpected visit to his sister at Collins House, pleaded the cause of his son….the ‘poor nine-year old child, with no mother to care for him’. He appealed to Elizabeth’s family pride, skillfully reminded her that David was the heir to the Collins name, faithfully promised a renewal of responsibility and sobriety” (Shadows on the Wall, pp. 25-26).

Yet since Roger’s return there has been nothing but trouble. Burke Devlin is back in town, leaving Elizabeth Stoddard apprehensive over the future of the Collins family business holdings and even of Collinwood itself. Her plant manager Bill Malloy is dead, after having vowed to stop Burke from carrying out his vendetta against the Collins family. Even Carolyn is affected, what with the worldly sophistication of Burke’s attention setting up a speed bump in her relationship with Joe Haskell, which at any time could sprout up into a full roadblock. All because Roger couldn’t accept the permanence, not to mention the more modest living arrangement, of his paid exile away from Collinwood and Collinsport in general.

People elsewhere in Collinsport are affected, even those with no apparent relationship with the Collins family, like Sam Evans. Although Sam’s involvement in the events of ten years earlier that sent Burke Devlin to prison on a manslaughter charge and conviction hasn’t yet been made explicitly clear, he shares the guilt that Roger holds but suffers greatly as a result whether or not the threat of exposure is looming close by. Sam represents a different shade of guilty largely because his character is more complex; for one thing, unlike Roger, he has a conscience, while Roger on the other hand, after nearly five dozen episodes of daily half-hour soap opera, has yet to display in his character so much as a single redeeming human quality.

So what do you do with this walking collection of red check marks down a list of boxes outlining the more questionable traits of human nature? If you’re the creator of the character, like Art Wallace who authored the above-mentioned series bible that serves as the show’s guiding outline of probable events, or the executive producer Dan Curtis, who is struggling to pull the sagging ratings back up to a level that would safeguard the show from an almost certain cancellation later that year, you simply provide your viewing audience with a much needed wave of satisfaction by having the character killed off.

That’s what the original plan called for; with Roger burdened by his desperate need to suppress the truth of his guilt in sending Burke Devlin away to prison, he will begin to suspect that Collinwood’s recently installed governess is conspiring against him when she is invited over to dinner at the Evans cottage, suspicious of what she may have been told about the events of ten years ago especially with the way Sam’s penchant for excessive drinking tends to loosen his tongue. Roger will then lure Vicki out to Widow’s Hill and standing by the edge he will in a fevered moment of rage grab hold of her, reminding her of the legend of Collinwood, how two young women of Collins House had hurled themselves over the edge and that at some future time there would be a third, and Vicki unnerved by the crazed look in Roger’s eyes begins to struggle against his grip; but David having followed them out to the cliff rushes forward and cries out, and Roger in that split second of surprise loses his footing and goes over the edge himself… and who among the viewing audience that afternoon in the summer or fall of sixty-six would have missed him?

Somewhere, in an alternate universe perhaps accessible through some warp of parallel time as yet undiscovered in one of Collinwood’s closed off wings, there was an end to Roger Collins after however many weeks of the series; in the series bible it happens the day Vicki takes David over to the Evans cottage so he can meet Sam the artist, so roughly early on in the phoenix story. In that parallel present time, Louis Edmonds decides once again to give up on acting, just as he had earlier that year when a steady stream of acting roles in the theater had at last dried up; his swan song as an actor would have been a bit part in a movie that filmed just before he started working on Dark Shadows called Come Spy with Me, a typical spy drama of the time released the following January that met with critical hostility and tepid box office attendance. Instead, he would have simply retired to his Long Island residence known as the Rookery, resigned to the humble but satisfying life of being a regular in the local shops and singing in the choir every Sunday, and some other actor would have landed the part of Langley Wallingford on All My Children in 1979.

To think what might have been were the makers of Dark Shadows not the type of people who could appreciate the talent of actors who would distinguish themselves in their roles so much so that they would actually be willing to dispense with a key moment in a given story outline. But that turning point is still weeks ahead; for now, Roger the rogue is doing what he can between brandies to keep the truth of his deeds both past and present from spilling into view and exposing him for all to see.

In retrospect, it’s easy to think of Louis Edmonds as indispensable to Dark Shadows in the role of Roger Collins. But if you were among the viewing audience during the summer of 1966 taking things in for the very first time, your attitude toward the character may have been different and your thoughts on the actor if any may well have likewise been indifferent. You may have caught a glimpse of his television work in more recent years on an episode of the short-lived series Mr. Broadway, but unless you had been a regular attendee of Broadway theater productions from the late fifties to early sixties chances are excellent that as a viewer of daytime TV in the summer of 1966 your introduction to Louis Edmonds would have been as Roger Collins on Dark Shadows, and as the series was wrapping up its eleventh week on the air with episode 55, you probably couldn’t stand him – Roger Collins, that is.

First impressions are everything, so let’s review what kind of an impression the character of Roger would have made on the viewer during the first week of the show.

Roger is a terrible parent. Here’s that memorable opening scene of the debut episode, with Roger taking his evening remedy in the form of a brandy and his sister Elizabeth taking her equivalent by standing at the drawing room window for the soothing sea breezes coming in off the water.

As usual, Roger is attempting to insinuate himself into the running of the household by talking Elizabeth into changing her mind about bringing a governess on to tutor his son. When you think of it, the timing is odd; up till now, David had been attending regular school while living up north in Augusta, and now here it is the start of what should be his summer vacation and his aunt Elizabeth is nonetheless wasting no time in ensuring that he gets home-schooled week in and week out ad infinitum. No wonder David can’t stand the sight of Victoria Winters when she first arrives at Collinwood.

Elizabeth attempts to deflect the various issues her brother raises by reminding him of his responsibilities as a parent:

Elizabeth: Don’t you think you ought to look in on your son?

Roger: The little monster’s asleep, and I’m delighted.

Roger and Elizabeth_opening scene_episode 1 (2)_ep55

The callous paternal indifference of the idle rich, as reinforced by that haughty, landed English brogue of Louis Edmonds. If the boy has problems, it’s no wonder.

Roger is creepy. We’ve all done this at one time, startled someone unintentionally when coming up from behind, and it’s the most embarrassing thing. But in episode 2, despite his rote apology afterward, one senses that Roger is rather shameless and calculating about creeping up behind the new governess without so much as a word – while she’s standing at the edge of a cliff.

Location footage for Widow's Hill_near Seaview Terrace_Roger approaches (2)_episode 2_ep53

If that weren’t enough, while putting on pleasant airs in the midst of making general small talk, Roger’s demeanor shifts with a sudden sharpness at the mention of Burke Devlin’s name and with such intensity that he unnerves Vicki by gripping both her arms with alarming force before turning and darting away just as suddenly.

Roger reacts when Vicki mentions Devlin's name_ep2

Roger is incredibly rude. Another episode, another Roger moment. When Roger needs to call on someone he knows in the middle of the night, his flair for the dramatic exceeds that of the viewer’s wildest imagination, but does provide one with a moment of unintended comical entertainment nonetheless:

Roger [calling for Sam Evans]: Answer yer doah, ya drunken bum!

Roger_Evans cottage_ep3 GIF

Roger is a prowler. It’s now the fourth episode, still Victoria Winters’ first night in Collinwood, and Roger has suddenly decided that he needs to talk with the young governess once more. The problem: It’s after midnight, and she’s in her room getting ready to turn in, unnerved by the slamming of the front door from downstairs.

A door is slammed in the night_ep4

No problem for Roger, though, as he creeps up the stairs and along the hallway outside Vicki’s room with a prowler’s patented stealth…

Footsteps in the hall outside Vicki's room_ep4

…intent on entering without permission and without so much as even a knock.

Roger at Vicky's door_GIF_ep4

Fortunately Elizabeth intervenes and orders him to wait for her downstairs. Roger eventually prevails in getting Vicki to come down to the drawing room so that he can talk with her further on the subject of Burke Devlin, but not before making her wait while he casually indulges in a late brandy…

Roger makes Vicky wait while he enjoys a spot of brandy_ep4

…and then subjecting her to caustic innuendo relating to certain rites of passage.

Roger: Nothing quite so satisfying as a fine brandy. You should try some.

Vicki: I have. It burns.

Roger [laughs]: The directness of youth. Pain sometimes precedes pleasure, Miss Winters, or are you too young to have discovered that yet?

Vicki: I’d rather avoid the pain as long as possible.

Roger is shamelessly incestuous. What wealthy dysfunctional household would be complete without the matriarch’s younger brother flirting openly and routinely with her daughter? The number of times Carolyn is referred to as “kitten” in the series rivals the instances where young David is referred to as a “little monster” – too many to count without a score pad.

Roger leans in to kiss Carolyn (kitten)_ep5

And that’s Roger Collins in a nutshell, episode by episode, through the first week of Dark Shadows. What’s not to dislike?

Roger’s only interest lies in protecting his dark secret from the past, so much so that it’s anyone’s guess to what lengths he may go to achieve that end. When Bill Malloy showed up at Collinwood in episode 46 to advise Roger to be at the meeting he’d set up for later that night, Roger had been pushed almost to the brink of a breakdown, in the process even admitting to Malloy his guilt in the manslaughter conviction that instead had sent Burke Devlin to prison ten years ago. Roger’s downfall had been all but written up; but over the next hour, something had transpired to change that outcome, as epitomized in this exchange between Roger and Sam Evans during the interval where Burke steps out to check on Malloy at his house, with Roger once again steadfast and determined toward keeping the truth from being discovered.

Roger explains to Sam why they must stand together_ep55

Roger is back in control, and by the time Burke has returned and the meeting is brought to a halt he is by then jubilant at having turned out none the poorer; just observe how he adds a particular lilt to the word “yes” to rub a bit of salt in Burke’s wounds.

Roger calls an end to the meeting (episode 47)_ep55

As an example of how Roger must remain a virtual stranger to even those closest in relation, following the late-night meeting at his office he must also allay any threat of suspicion on the home front, which means deflecting any inquiries from his sister Elizabeth who is intent on finding out why her plant manager had that day become so heated on the subject of Roger in relation to Burke Devlin. Startled to find his sister there in the drawing room as he enters for a nightcap of brandy, Roger attempts to defuse the sharpness of her mood: “I thought you’d stopped waiting up for me” is an allusion to how according to the series bible Shadows on the Wall Elizabeth being some twenty years older than he had practically raised Roger as a mother figure following the death of her own mother Carolyn while giving birth to Roger. When that fails, Roger must resort to simply being evasive.

Roger attempts to diffuse the sharpness of Elizabeth's mood (episode 47)_ep55

Roger says he was at a business meeting (2)_episode 47_ep48

After talking his way around his sister’s probing questions by assuring her that he’ll provide all the information she wants if she organizes a meeting with Bill Malloy once he returns from wherever it is he’s gone off to, Roger then does something quite amusing – he sends Elizabeth to bed as though he’s the master of the house and she is instead twenty years the junior.

Roger sends Elizabeth off to bed_pt 1_episode 47_ep55

Roger sends Elizabeth off to bed_pt 1 (2)_episode 47_ep55

In episode 50 Roger is sending her off to bed yet again. In episode 48, Elizabeth had found out that Roger had lied to her on the night of the meeting about not having seen Bill Malloy since earlier that day.

Elizabeth [on the phone with Roger in episode 48]: Hello, Roger? I’d like to see you at once… I don’t care what you’re doing at the moment. This is more important… Alright… Well didn’t you tell me that you hadn’t seen Bill Malloy since early yesterday afternoon?… Well I’ve just learned differently. And I’d like an explanation from you… No, I have no intention of discussing it on the telephone. I want you here and now!

Episode 50 [Roger explaining to Elizabeth where he’d been all day]:

Elizabeth: Where have you been all evening?

Roger: Obviously I don’t have to ask you that question. I know where you’ve been. For the past eighteen years, right here in this lovely old house.

Elizabeth [sharply]: When I called I asked you to come right home.

Roger: I know.

Elizabeth: I meant at that moment, not hours later.

Roger: Did it ever occur to you that I might have something more pressing to do?

Elizabeth: More important than Bill Malloy’s disappearance?

Roger: I’ve been just as concerned about it as you have. When I left the office, right after you telephoned, I had every intention of coming right back here… as you so forcefully suggested. Then I had a feeling that I might be able to find him. So I drove out to his cousins’ house. Well, it’s a long trip. And a completely wasted one. They hadn’t seen him for weeks. Hadn’t heard from him in days. And then I came right back here. Does that answer all your questions?

Elizabeth: Why didn’t you call and tell me where you were going?

Roger: Well I meant to, but it slipped my mind. I simply forgot.

Elizabeth: Did you also forget to tell me that you saw Bill here last night?

Roger: How did you know that?

Elizabeth: It doesn’t matter. I want to know why he was here.

Incidentally, that story above about Roger driving out to Bill Malloy’s cousins’ house was a lie that Elizabeth being an estate-bound recluse had no means of checking on, as detailed in her phone call to Malloy’s housekeeper Mrs. Johnson, also in episode 48:

Elizabeth [on the phone with Mrs. Johnson]: I was wondering if Mr. Malloy said anything about visiting friends or his cousins… I see. Well no, I can’t check with them, they have no phone.

Once Roger is certain he’s again in the clear, he calls an end to the night by sending Elizabeth off to bed.

Roger sends Elizabeth off to bed_pt 2_episode 50_ep55

Next episode, Elizabeth is back downstairs because she couldn’t sleep for worrying about Bill Malloy; despite all the excitement of a body having been allegedly spotted at the bottom of Widow’s Hill by Vicki and Carolyn, all Roger has to do is send her back to bed and she complies – at least she leaves him alone in the drawing room with his troubled thoughts.

Roger sends Elizabeth off to bed_pt 3_episode 51_ep55

Roger after having sent Elizabeth up to bed_ep55

With each passing day Roger is faced with yet another renewed struggle in covering his tracks, especially when the sheriff stops in at Collinwood with questions about Malloy. At the start of episode 55 Roger is ostensibly hearing about Bill’s death for the first time, yet we know from episode 54 that Roger seems to have had prior knowledge given how at his office he was instructing employees with new systems of operation he had implemented and threatening them with their job if they failed to comply. How about this reaction of Roger to the news: convincing enough for Elizabeth and the sheriff, but hokey and comical to the viewer:

Roger reacting to the news of Bill Malloy_ep55

It’s during this occasion when the general incompetence of the sheriff of Collinsport first becomes apparent. When Sheriff Patterson remarks that Roger may have been the last person to see Bill Malloy alive, Elizabeth informs him that she had been talking to Malloy’s housekeeper Mrs. Johnson and says that Bill had been home that night at ten thirty and got a phone call.

Sheriff Patterson: Well, I can check that out with Mrs. Johnson.

Sheriff Patterson is told about the phone call Bill Malloy received at ten thirty_ep55

A sheriff who knows his job would just check it out with the phone company.

There’s an episode of The Untouchables from 1959 called The Underground Railway, where a mob figure named Frank Holloway breaks out of prison to travel cross-country to collect the half million in cash from the robbery being held by an associate.

(The) Untouchables_The Underground Railway_opening_ep55

The Underground Railway is so named because it refers to a hidden network of stopovers scattered around the country that allow well-connected figures on the run to move about without being detected, and with a mug like Holloway’s one could see why he would need to be traveling incognito.

(Cliff Robertson in heavy makeup as Frank Holloway)

(The) Untouchables_The Underground Railway_Frank Holloway in closeup_ep55

Eliot Ness however has a clue about who it was that planned Holloway’s itinerary.

Eliot Ness (Robert Stack) pays a visit to Daniel Oates (Joe De Santis).

(The) Untouchables_The Underground Railway_Eliot Ness drops in on Daniel Oates_ep55

Agents Flaherty (Jerry Paris, right) and Rossman (Steve London, left) are then sent to the phone company to check on Oates’ business and home phone records, after obtaining a court order.

(The) Untouchables_The Underground Railway_agents checking on phone records_ep55

Agent Rossman with the telephone company supervisor, checking further on phone records for notification of Oates’ next move.

(The) Untouchables_The Underground Railway_Agent Rossman with the telephone company supervisor_ep55

The above Untouchables episode was set in 1933 Pennsylvania, so it isn’t like 1966 Collinsport wouldn’t have such capability, that is provided the sheriff is indeed intent on checking into the circumstances of Malloy’s death from all possible angles as he claims. But such is the state of Collinsport law enforcement in the post–Jonas Carter era.

Recall how back in episode 46 Roger was on the phone with someone when Vicki walked into the drawing room; he had been asking someone to meet him somewhere.

Roger on the phone at ten fifteen_Act IV episode 46_ep47

Given the recent suspicious actions of caretaker Matthew Morgan in hiding the fact of Malloy’s death by pushing the body back out to sea the night it washes up on the rocks below Widow’s Hill, a different scenario is beginning to develop: that maybe Roger was on the phone with Matthew to meet him so he could use the caretaker as muscle to dispose of Malloy.

The subject of Roger’s mysterious phone call that night will be revisited again, more than once.

Looking less guilty in the disappearance of Malloy is Sam Evans; yet Sam shares with Roger a certain degree of guilt with regard to their pact of silence relating to Burke Devlin’s manslaughter conviction. But unlike Roger, Sam seems to be taking Malloy’s disappearance especially hard.

David Ford as Sam Evans_ep55

Perhaps Sam is worried that what happened to Malloy could happen to him as well, given that it was he who in a drunken moment had supplied Malloy with the information that would lead to the meeting being arranged to begin with. Wound up in a fit of angst, he reminds Maggie about the letter he gave her, asking if she’d put it away in a safe place.

Sam asks Maggie about the letter he gave her to be put away (2)_ep55

You can really feel the tension Sam is consumed by, and scenes like this emphasize the great and natural chemistry for the father-daughter relationship being portrayed as embodied by David Ford and the actress who plays Maggie Evans.

Sam wants Maggie to get him the letter he wrote for her_ep55

This episode lets Sam off the hook with regard to suspicion in Malloy’s disappearance and death, because despite the motive and opportunity, Sam unlike Roger still doesn’t know that Bill is dead.

Maggie: But Pop, Mr. Malloy is a fair man. Maybe he can help you.

Sam: Yes, yes. Maybe he is the one man who can help me.

Sam and Maggie Evans_ep55

Meanwhile back at Collinwood when asked if anyone else at the plant can verify that Bill Malloy had requested him there for a late meeting in his office, Roger provides the names of two other men who were present…

Roger reveals the presence of Burke and Sam at the meeting_ep55

…which naturally comes as a surprise to Elizabeth given what her brother had previously told her about the meeting that night.

Elizabeth reacts to Roger's revelation about Burke and Sam being at the meeting (2)_ep55

After seeing the sheriff out the front door, Elizabeth confronts Roger: “How much of what you told him was the truth?”

Elizabeth confronts Roger about his lies to the sheriff and to her_ep55

Roger: Don’t you see that Burke Devlin is out to murder me? He’s out to destroy me!

Elizabeth: Bill said he had some evidence that could set aside Burke’s conviction.

Roger: Lies, all lies! If you can ever accept that premise, then you will believe me. You’ve got to believe me.

Roger denounces Bill's premise as lies (2)_ep55

That’s Roger’s one saving grace; his sister’s unwavering allegiance to what it means to be a Collins of Collinsport.

Elizabeth: Yes, I have to. I have to believe you.

Elizabeth has no choice but to believe Roger_ep55

From the control room:

The series: The Dan and Lela Show; the main players: director Lela Swift, executive producer Dan Curtis; the setting: television studio control room; main prop: the control room microphone; opening scene: main theme…

More extensive control room discussion taken from the tapings of episodes 53, 54, and 55 will be examined together at length in an upcoming post, after the move to the new studio has been made. Here in episode 55, director Lela Swift has mainly two things on her mind as expressed during the opening and closing themes.


Dan: Lela, will you just please leave it alone?

Lela: No I won’t leave it alone. Dan, I want you to fire Mitch Ryan. He told me to go fuck myself, right from the soundstage.

Dan: Lela, I have other things on my mind…

Below is an audio clip (of just under 2 seconds) to provide a glimpse of how Lela sounds when asserting herself through the control room microphone. This occurs during a break in dialogue in the middle of Act III as the scene transitions from the Collinsport Inn restaurant to the Collinwood foyer, and provides an idea of how well such discussions coming through the control room microphone could be heard throughout the television studio and also how easy it is to pick up such things as Lela’s distinctive voice through the layers of audio as heard throughout the overall broadcast by the fine art of “selective audio focus” as I call it:

[Middle of Act III, transition from Collinsport Inn restaurant to Collinwood foyer]

Lela: Dan, you heard something!

To get better acquainted with the general sound and tone of Lela’s voice during one of her frequent scraps with her executive producer as they oversee the videotaping from the control room, here’s the above clip put on a loop so that it can be heard three times back to back:

Lela: …you heard something!

[closing theme]

Lela: Dan, I’m not thrilled with the idea of working in a converted lumber yard.

Dan: Lela, we’ve got to do this to keep Alexandra on the show. This way, she won’t have to keep coming to the same dressing room all the time.

Lela: But Dan, this studio is state-of-the-art…

Bob Lloyd [ABC announcer]: The king is coming. Watch the advance premiere of the Milton Berle Show in color, tonight on ABC.

Dan: …The next studio will have everything this studio has.

Lela: But Dan, I’m going to miss this control room…

Bob Lloyd: Dark Shadows is a Dan Curtis production.

Dan: Don’t worry, Lela, you’ll adjust…

Until next time, this has been The Dan and Lela Show.

Background/Production Notes:

Episode 55 is the last to be taped at ABC Studio 2 on 24 West 67th Street in New York. Starting with episode 56 and continuing all the way to the end of the series in 1971, production will take place at a location newly converted from an old lumber yard, ABC Studio 16 at 453 West 53rd Street. To accommodate the move, Dark Shadows took one week off from production from August 29 until September 5, while episodes from the two-week backlog of videotapings were used to maintain the normal broadcast schedule. As a result, over the next few months there would only be at most a one-week lag in the videotaping schedule from production to broadcast, which eventually would cause tension behind the scenes where at one point the time span between taping and broadcast gets reduced to a mere two days, requiring Dan Curtis to make an emergency decision of preemption later in the year to restore the comfort zone between production and broadcast. The reason for changing studio locations is provided in the “From the control room” section of the post for episode 53.

Below is a brief audio clip (11 seconds) from the control room discussion on the subject between Dan Curtis and Lela Swift during the opening scene of episode 53, where in a converted WAV (“wave”) audio file with the sound amplified you can hear (with headphones, in the left channel) the following:

Dan: Goddamn that fucking Mark Allen for ruining my show like that.

Lela: Dan, what are we going to do about Alexandra?

Here is a clip where Dan’s voice is put on a loop so that it can be heard back to back five times (for a total of 18 seconds):

Dan: Goddamn that fucking Mark Allen…

As of 2017, ABC Studio 16 was demolished to make way for a residential property. However, because the original Dark Shadows production location of ABC Studio 2 is part of the Upper West Side/Central Park West Historic District, this building still stands.

(ABC Studio 2 on 24 West 67th Street, in a November 2017 Google Street view)

Dark Shadows_Television studios_24 West 57th Street_Google Street View_November 2017_ep55

During Act II, while Roger recounts for the sheriff the night of the meeting Bill Malloy called in his office, there is a rare scripted mention of a “doorbell” when he describes how Burke stepped out to check on Malloy at his house and that no one had answered the front doorbell. Thus far, a front doorbell has only been heard at one residence, the Evans cottage, over three episodes (7, 22, 49), all when Burke Devlin comes calling on Sam unannounced. The sound effect used for the Evans cottage front doorbell is a buzzing sound, the same sound effect used for the telephone intercom system in Roger’s office in episode 54.

Daily studio schedule for Dark Shadows in 1966

7:00-11:00 a.m.   Lighting

8:30-10:30           Morning Rehearsal

10:30-11:30         Break/Make-Up

11:00-12:00         Engineering Set-Up

11:30-2:00           Camera Blocking & Run Through

2:00-2:30             Dress Rehearsal

2:30-3:00             Test Pattern

3:00-3:30             Episode Taping

3:30-4:00             Knockdown

3:45-4:15             Technical Meeting

4:00-6:30             Dry Rehearsal for Next Episode

4:00-7:00             Reset Studio

Set Design:

Yesterday the Collinsport Inn phone booth was in the lobby facing the front entrance, while today it’s back in the restaurant. Just as with the hotel lobby, the revolving phone booth has faced different angles in the restaurant, including the counter (episode 28) and the doors to the lobby (episode 40). Today it faces straight across to the main restaurant entrance beyond the counter.

Phone booth facing front door in diner_ep55

Of special note, Maggie answers an incoming call as “Collinsport Restaurant.” Over the first year, the Collinsport Inn restaurant will be referred to by many names, including restaurant, coffee shop, and even by Roger on two occasions as the hotel café, but this is only the second time in the series thus far where this establishment is referred to as it was originally scripted at the very beginning of the series. The one previous occasion was in episode 29, when Maggie phones Collinwood to let them know where David has run away to and Carolyn describes the caller for Elizabeth: “It’s Maggie Evans. She works in the Collinsport Restaurant.”

It's Maggie Evans_she works in the Collinsport Restaurant_ep29

Collinsport Restaurant, as named in page 3 of a script for episode 1; image from: Dark Shadows: The First Year, by Nina Johnson and O. Crock (summary writers), Blue Whale Books, 2006.

Page 3 of original script for episode 1

Bloopers/Story Continuity:

In Act I, as Elizabeth answer’s Roger’s question about what Matthew had done, Joan Bennett says the line, “Matthew didn’t want Bill’s body discovered at Collinswood.”

In Act I, at the Collinsport Inn restaurant, as Sam considers trying to phone Bill Malloy at his office, a shift in camera position allows the glare of a studio light to intrude in the upper right corner of the frame.

Glare of studio light_Act I_ep55

In Act II, as Sam and Maggie discuss the letter he gave her to put away in the hotel safe, the camera bumps into something causing the frame to momentarily shudder.

In Act III, as Sheriff Patterson ponders what Mrs. Stoddard has just told him about Ned Calder in relation to Bill Malloy’s position at the plant, the shadow of the camera can be seen against the sheriff’s uniform; not really intrusive if you instead think of it as a piece of drawing room furniture, which it sort of is.

Camera blooper_shadow of camera equipment against Sheriff Patterson's uniform_Act III_ep55

Momentarily in Act IV, the camera blocking goes off while both Roger and Elizabeth move forward toward the camera, but it appears that the cameraman has failed to move back to accommodate the shot, leaving the actors each half in and half out of frame.

Camera blooper_blocking momentarily fails in Act IV_ep55


This episode provides yet another glimpse of the portrait that hangs over the liquor cabinet in the drawing room, which one may assume somewhat resembles how Louis Edmonds would appear as Joshua Collins in 1795.

Propspotting_Collinwood drawing room_liquor cabinet_portrait of Wagner (apparent)_ep55

But here in 1966, the character of Joshua was still more than a year away from being created; as originally envisioned in Art Wallace’s story outline Shadows on the Wall, the great estate of Collinwood was built in 1830 by Jeremiah Collins.

To this end, scenic designer Sy Tomashoff went searching through antique shops to find portrait paintings that would help to emphasize the nineteenth century type of ambience the Collinwood drawing room was constructed to emulate.

A commenter in the post for episode 32, What It Means to Be a Collins of Collinsport, contributed by identifying this portrait as one of the composer Richard Wagner, which makes sense given how it serves to reinforce the overall period feel of that century.

The image of the German composer of the Romantic Period shown in the drawing room was undoubtedly based on the following image…

Wagner (Richard)_portrait (right profile)

…modeled after a contemporary portrait…

Wagner portrait

…which is similar to how Wagner looked in this 1873 photograph.

Wagner photograph_1873

Food & Drink in Collinsport:

At the top of Act I, Roger prepares himself for the sheriff’s questioning with a good stiff glass of brandy. As can be seen, the glass is still half full, even after he has already taken a healthy sip from it, whereas ordinarily he only pours enough for a sip or two.

Roger holding a glass of brandy_Act I_ep55

As the scene switches back to the Collinwood drawing room for the final third of Act I, Elizabeth is serving coffee from a service tray. Sheriff Patterson graciously accepts while Roger, still on edge over the news of Bill Malloy washing ashore at Collinwood, sharply refuses.

Elizabeth serves coffee in the drawing room_Act I_ep55

With the start of Act II, Maggie brings for Pop a black coffee and cheese danish, which apart from the coffee Sam cannot bring himself to enjoy because he is instead brooding over alphabet soup; that is, the letter he gave to Maggie back in episode 37 to put in the hotel safe.

Maggie bringing Sam a coffee and danish_Act II_ep55

In the middle of Act III, as Sam broods away at his table while chain smoking, Maggie takes a food order over the phone from Burke, who wants it sent up to his room. Whatever it is, probably a sandwich, Burke wants lots of mayonnaise on it. One can rule out ham, because back in episode 24 when ordering a ham sandwich to take back to his hotel room, he had it made with cheese and “butter and mustard, no lettuce”; so it’s probably a roast beef he’s ordering here in this episode. Maggie asks if he wants coffee as well, because that’s what people did in 1966; a sandwich and a coffee. Stay nourished and alert, especially in Collinsport when you just never know what the next scene will bring.

Maggie takes a food order from Burke (2)_Act III_ep55

A minute later as the scene continues and Maggie jokes with Pop over the possible contents of the letter he wrote for her to put away, after spreading mayonnaise on a slice of white bread Maggie can be seen topping it with what indeed looks to be a strip of lean roast beef. As can be seen from the menu board on the back wall, fourth item up from the bottom, in 1966 a roast beef sandwich at the Collinsport Inn restaurant went for a dollar and a quarter ($9.88 in 2019 currency).

Maggie prepares the sandwich Burke called in to order_Act III_ep55

After thanking Mrs. Stoddard for the coffee and while wrapping up their discussion in the foyer, Sheriff Patterson brings up the fact that Bill Malloy was seen in the Blue Whale drinking in the hours leading up to his disappearance and wonders if this may have affected his behavior enough to have led to his accidentally falling in the water. The sheriff remarks that his housekeeper, Mrs. Johnson, would surely have noticed given that she is a teetotaler.

Sheriff Patterson describes Mrs. Johnson as a teetotaler_Act III_ep55

At the top of Act IV, after the sheriff has left and his sister making reference to “the ghosts of your past” accuses him of lying to both the sheriff and her, Roger retreats into the drawing room for another brandy: “Very well, I and my ghosts want a drink! My nerves are shot.”

Roger has a second brandy (2)_Act IV_ep55

Despite having already been served coffee up at Collinwood, Sheriff Patterson drops in at the diner for another coffee and asks also for a donut. He makes small-talk with Sam about his art work while Maggie pours his coffee, which he won’t get to drink because he gets called away with news that the Coast Guard had just pulled Bill Malloy’s body out of the water. Funny how the Coast Guard would be calling for the sheriff through the pay phone of a local coffee shop, rather than the sheriff’s office. But then again, Sheriff Patterson’s deputy is out with Matthew at Widow’s Hill, so at that moment there’s probably no one in the sheriff’s office to answer any incoming calls.

Sheriff Patterson makes small-talk with Sam Evans at Collinsport Inn restaurant_Act IV_ep55

As Maggie goes round the counter to field the phone call, Sheriff Patterson can be seen reaching for a sugar container to sweeten his coffee.

Sheriff Patterson reaches for the sugar to sweeten his coffee_Act IV_ep55

The sheriff only gets to handle the donut he ordered, before Maggie alerts him that the call is for him.

Sheriff Patterson with a donut in his hand_Act IV_ep55

A change in camera angle reveals this to be a plain donut.

Sheriff Patterson holding a plain donut_Act IV_ep55

While the sheriff is taking his phone call, Sam tells Maggie that he has to leave. It can be seen that even though the sheriff ordered just “one of those donuts” there are in fact two plain donuts on his plate. The other donuts, all plain, are stacked in the glass domed holder on the counter which also doubles as a pie holder, as it will in episode 72 when Mrs. Johnson is served “fresh” baked apple pie during lunch.

Sam tells Maggie that he has to leave the restaurant_ep55

On the Flipside:

Over the closing theme of episode 50, ABC announcer Bob Lloyd provides the following message: “The famed Green Hornet comes to television. Watch the advance premiere of The Green Hornet in color one week from tonight, here on ABC.”

The “advance premiere” was a strategy where the ABC network sought to gain ground on their two more venerable competitors NBC and CBS by airing newer programs from their fall 1966 lineup one week earlier, ahead of the official start of the new network television season which would begin on Monday September 12.

With Dark Shadows episode 55 airing on Friday September 9 at 4:00 p.m. Eastern standard time (EST), ABC was providing an advance premiere for two new shows in its Friday evening lineup: The Green Hornet at 7:30 EST and The Time Tunnel from 8:00 to 9:00 EST.

Although The Green Hornet was making its television debut, the character was already part of a franchise that extended back three decades, beginning with a radio series in the 1930s and film serials in the 1940s as well as several varied series of comic books that decade, beginning with Green Hornet Comics written by Green Hornet co-creator Fran Striker.

Similar to other crime-fighting cartoon icons of the day like Batman and Superman, the Green Hornet is the alter-ego of Britt Reid who publishes the Daily Sentinel newspaper, but who fights crime in a vigilante disguise of green mask, gloves, and overcoat while, also like Batman, tooling around the city in a souped-up wonder car nicknamed the Black Beauty. In yet another parallel with Batman, the Green Hornet has as his faithful ally Kato who in his masked incarnation is Green Hornet’s bodyguard/assistant/enforcer, but who by day is Britt Reid’s chauffeur.

The debut episode of The Green Hornet is called The Silent Gun. How silent is the silent gun? The silent gun is so silent, that you can take it out among a crowd of people during a funeral service…

Green Hornet_Silent Gun (1)_ep55

…and just kill some guy…

Green Hornet_Silent Gun (2)_ep55

…so that no one would know, not even the police who are present in the background.

Green Hornet_Silent Gun (3)_ep55

Forget the police, this is a job for the Green Hornet.

Green Hornet_logo GIF_ep55

Noteworthy is that The Green Hornet provided television viewers with their first glimpse of Bruce Lee, who played Green Hornet’s faithful assistant Kato.

Green Hornet_opening theme (1)_ep55

Given the Batman similarities noted above, it should come as no surprise that Van Williams’ Green Hornet and Bruce Lee’s Kato would appear on episodes of Batman that season, especially since both shows were products of Greenway Productions and executive produced by William Dozier, who also did the narration for both.

With The Green Hornet on at 7:30 p.m. each Friday night, you can be sure that plenty of kids were tuning in. Let’s see what the ABC advertising executives in 1966 were pitching to their prospective younger audience: “V is for… Viceroy?”

The Green Hornet is brought to you by…Viceroy.”

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (1)_ep55

“Viceroy’s got the taste that’s right, right any time of the day.”

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (2)_ep55

The lines are all straining, over 4000 pounds; mister, take her away

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (3)_ep55

Then a Viceroy smoke for the taste that’s right

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (5)_ep55

Right any time of the day

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (6)_ep55

This is the good taste you always get

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (7)_ep55

When you smoke the Viceroy way

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (8)_ep55

Cause a Viceroy smoke’s got the taste that’s right

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (9)_ep55

Right any time of the day

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (10)_ep55

“Viceroy is the filter cigarette blended with natural flavor fresheners, to enrich and improve true tobacco taste”

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (11)_ep55

“That’s why Viceroy tastes rich, good, rewarding, any time you light up”

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (12)_ep55

You’re well out to sea, doin’ 17 knots

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (13)_ep55

Now’s the time when you say

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (14)_ep55

Give me a Viceroy smoke

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (15)_ep55

It’s got the taste that’s right

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (16)_ep55

Right any time of the day

Green Hornet_Silent Gun_Viceroy commercial (17)_ep55

Green Hornet_opening logo_ep55

Following The Green Hornet is a one-hour time travel adventure series called The Time Tunnel, created and produced by Irwin Allen who is perhaps best known for his 1970s TV disaster movies like The Towering Inferno.

As part of a secret government endeavor called Project TicToc, 12,000 personnel working 800 stories deep in a secret complex in an Arizona desert set to work building a time machine, with the focus on three researchers in particular played by James Darren, Robert Colbert, and Lee Meriwether.

Time Tunnel_depth of complex (2)_ep55

In addition to the intriguing subject matter, The Time Tunnel is also technically and visually impressive, even after more than fifty years on, as one of the researchers takes a visiting senator on a tour of the complex, beginning with a freefall elevator system which takes them 800 floors deep.

Time Tunnel_freefall elevator_ep55

For a television production, they really go all out in set design. It was rumored that The Time Tunnel had the biggest budget of any television show of its day, and one look at the wide angle views of the sets would explain why.

Time Tunnel_set design_ep55

Time Tunnel_set design (2)_ep55

(Lee Meriwether as Dr. Ann McGregor)

Time Tunnel_Lee Meriwether as Dr. Ann McGegor_ep55

(A crew member at work in the time tunnel)

Time Tunnel_crew member in the tunnel_ep55

James Darren (center) as Dr. Anthony Newman and Robert Colbert (right) as Dr. Doug Phillips, addressing Senator Leroy Clark (Gary Merrill)

Time Tunnel_Drs. Newman and Phillips (3)_ep55

The project has been going on for ten years at the cost of $7.5 billion, so the senator demands fast, immediate action: Send a man back in time that very day, or he’ll return to Washington and cut off the funding.

Time Tunnel_Senator Clark demands fast action_ep55

Having put their lives into the project, Dr. Newman is determined that it be allowed to go ahead, so he programs the tunnel for operation himself when the laboratory is empty.

Time Tunnel_Dr. Newman at the controls_ep55

Then he rushes forward into the time tunnel.

Time Tunnel_Dr. Newman enters the time tunnels_ep55

Dr. Phillips and other personnel arrive on the scene, but too late to stop him.

Time Tunnel_Dr. Phillips and other personnel arrive too late to stop Newman_ep55

Dr. Phillips calls out a red alert, ordering all time tunnel personnel to report to their stations at once.

Time Tunnel_personnel respond to the red alert_ep55

As personnel wait through a crucial countdown, Dr. McGregor explains to the senator that Newman has entered into a radiation freeze, the first step in his relocation.

Time Tunnel_Dr. McGegor explains about the radiation freeze_ep55

During a location probe, it is determined that Newman has hurled himself back into the past and is aboard an ocean liner, a familiar four-stacker…

Time Tunnel_Titanic scale model_ep55

…which turns out to be the Titanic, on the day before its collision with the iceberg.

Time Tunnel_Dr. Newman finds he's on the Titanic_ep55

So back at the laboratory they’ve got to figure out a way to rescue him before it’s too late.

They’ve got the scale model of Titanic about right. For comparison, below is an image of Titanic’s elder sister ship Olympic from a colorized clip of British Movietone footage filmed in the 1930s, along with an audio clip of Olympic sounding her whistles as she communicates with nearby tugboats upon her entry into New York Harbor, also from the 1930s.

RMS Olympic_last voyage_colorized_GIF_ep55

(Images from the opening theme of The Time Tunnel, 1966)

Time Tunnel_opening theme (1)_ep55

Time Tunnel_opening theme (2)_ep55

Time Tunnel_opening theme (3)_ep55

Parallel Collinsport, 1966:

On the day episode 55 was taped, Friday August 26, 1966, music trio the Walker Brothers released their LP Portrait, featuring the widely covered Hurting Each Other.

Walker Brothers_Hurting Each Other_pp31-32_ep55

With their heavily orchestrated production sound and richly nuanced vocal harmonies, the Walker Brothers have been referred to as “the English Righteous Brothers”; originally based in Los Angeles, it was eventually decided that their approach would be met with greater success over in England. The Burt Bacharach and Hal David song Make It Easy On Yourself was their breakthrough hit on both sides of the Atlantic.

Walker Brothers_Make It Easy On Yourself_pp19-20_ep55

Moving their base of operations to London proved effective, as they enjoyed great success on the English charts, including their 1966 #1 hit The Sun Ain’t Gonna Shine Anymore.

Walker Brothers_Sun Aint Gonna Shine Anymore_pp25-26_ep55

There’s an interesting and lesser known background to the song – it was first recorded and released by Frankie Valli. Co-written by Four Seasons member Bob Gaudio and producer Bob Crewe, the song was recorded as The Sun Ain’t Gonna Shine (Anymore) during a 1965 Four Seasons recording session. Upon release the single went nowhere, most likely because the Four Seasons were still in the midst of their impressive chart run of hits, and the public just wasn’t ready yet for Frankie Valli as a solo act. Underrated as songwriters, music arrangers, and musicians, this recording shows that these Jersey boys really were crackerjack.

Four Seasons_Sun Aint Gonna Shine (Anymore)_pp38-29_ep55

Recommended Reading:

Joan Bennett’s 1970 autobiography (original front and back covers).

Joan Bennett cast member spotlight_The Bennett Playbill_front cover_ep25

Joan Bennett cast member spotlight_The Bennett Playbill_back cover_ep25

The Bennetts: An Acting Family, the 2004 biography (front cover).

Joan Bennett cast member spotlight_The Bennetts An Acting Family_front cover_ep25

Recommended Listening:

In this eight-CD box set of composer Robert Cobert’s series soundtrack, every music cue used on Dark Shadows is available, including the full-length original recordings of the guitar instrumentals heard at the Blue Whale.

Dark Shadows_Soundtrack Music Collection_Front cover

Since 2006, UK production company Big Finish has been extending the Dark Shadows legacy with audio dramas offering new stories featuring cast members from the original TV series. My favorite is the 2015 audio drama …And Red All Over, in which Mitchell Ryan reprises his role as Burke Devlin to the backdrop of an eerily compelling backstory on how he came to acquire his wealth in business. Also returning is the actress who played Maggie Evans, with original series themes and music cues composed by Robert Cobert. A must listen for any fan of the first year of Dark Shadows.

And Red All Over_CD booklet front image

Coming next: Episode 56: More Problems Dead Than Alive

— Marc Masse

(aka PrisoneroftheNight)

© 2019 Marc Masse and Dark Shadows

from the Beginning. All rights reserved.

Unauthorized use and/or duplication of

the content herein is a violation of the

terms and standards as set forth under

U.S. copyright law.

21 thoughts on “Episode 55: Two Shades of Guilty”

  1. @ Count Catofi (posted September 13, 2019 at 12:02 am)
    “Here’s a fun photo of 2 more DS smokers if this photo will post:”

    Dark Shadows from the Beginning supports this post and encourages all smokers everywhere to stand up for their dwindling rights.

    They may have banned cigarette ads from television, but they will never ban cigarette ads from television blogs.

  2. @Count Catofi:

    Yes, around the first of last month when those articles first appeared; it even made the general news feeds, in which he was touted as “set designer for The Bold and The Beautiful” etc. Same thing when Denise Nickerson passed a few weeks earlier, where the general news articles had her listed as the actress who played Violet Beauregarde in the Willie Wonka movie; the articles would list that she was also in an episode of The Brady Bunch, and only one as I recall even bothered to mention her work on Dark Shadows.

    It cannot be stated enough how essential Sy Tomashoff’s contribution to Dark Shadows was; it’s just beautiful to look at, because of his ground-breaking creative approach. Imagine if he’d approached the set design like any other ordinary soap of the day.

  3. I know. I wish he’d written a book detailing his set designs, a lost opportunity.

    In the post for episode 58, there will be a special spotlight feature on Dana Elcar. Mr. Elcar appeared in an episode of East Side, West Side, for which Sy Tomashoff was art director. In that feature, it will be opined that Sy Tomashoff had even more of an influence on Dark Shadows than set design, that he may have had a significant influence on casting as well. Stay tuned!

  4. Five seconds of the wonders of this new drug, followed by twenty seconds of contraindications ranging from skin irritation to death; then that cheery ending about ‘a day without…’, ‘ask your doctor about…’. Seems SO worth it!

  5. Yep. now as Prisoner said elsewhere, Pharma ads make TV unwatchable. “Ask your doctor about XYZtweedledeedlecol skin moisturizer. Side effects may include suicide, cancer, bubonic plague, and cravings for cold pizza.”

  6. We’ve come a long way, baby.

    I go waay back to when tobacco advertising and sponsorships permeated our culture in similar fashion to the way Big Pharm does now; an average hour of primetime TV had at least four cigarette ads, there were a dozen or so in any magazine (well, any one not specifically for kids), and smokes were giving big money to sponsor sports teams, NASCAR racing, golfing and about everything else.

  7. I bet Mrs. Johnson smoked unfiltered Camels.
    My mother smoked Virginia Slims – they were a bit longer, right? More sleek and elegant than regular cigs. Probably started with a subliminal idea for marketing cigarettes to women that Samantha hastily zapped into Darrin’s head cause Larry and their Phillip Morris client were ringing the front doorbell!

  8. Unfortunately, I doubt we’ll be able to detect the brand, even with a good-sized magnifying glass at the ready, given how shows like Dark Shadows were forbidden by ABC’s Department of Broadcast Standards and Practices from displaying brand names, which went under the heading of a “gratuitous plug” — not fair to the advertisers who had to pay for time during the commercial breaks. You can see when David brings food over to Matthew at the Old House how even those products have the brand names crossed out with black marker, like this one big box of what looks like Ronzoni pasta shells or something.

    It’ll be fun nonetheless to speculate on Mrs. Johnson’s brand… probably Viceroy. 🙂 Did you catch that blooper in that episode when David is stealing her cigarettes? While rushing to stuff the pack into his coat pocket, one of the ciggies slips out of the pack and falls to the floor, I believe David even breaks it in two as he hurries to conceal the pack — and of course Mrs. Johnson, who appears beside him a second later, fails to even notice! 🙂

    “This portion of Dark Shadows is brought to you by, Viceroy unfiltered. The pure tobacco flavor, that gives your coffee break that extra lift. Viceroy unfiltered, for that pure tobacco fullness. Your kids will like it too. Viceroy, the smoke worth stealing for!”

  9. @ Samantha,

    Sam Evans is also a smoker — in fact, right here in episode 55 he’s practically chain smoking; every time the scene switches back to the diner, Sam has another ciggie freshly lit. I suppose it goes with the territory of being a drinker. In episode 58, Sam will be in the Blue Whale puffing away when the sheriff shows up, and Patterson uses that as an excuse to get him to come down to his office for a little talk: “Oh boy, the smoke is terrible in here. Ah, let’s get out of here, what do you say?”

    Further on, Jason McGuire likes an occasional smoke, but only in style — during his stay, there will in the drawing room be a glass cigarette holder kept on the piano, filter side up, arranged like bread sticks on a restaurant dining table.

  10. Thanks Count, that is very interesting. Who were the smokers on DS? Willie, Burke, Julia – I saw Joe light up once. It sure was a different time – almost every adult I knew smoked. But then, I grew up in NC so, that’s no big surprise. My mother used to wash our walls twice a year to get the nicotine stains off. I bet Mrs. Johnson was happy she didn’t have to perform that particular task at Collinwood.

  11. I was afraid of that. But it did seem to be the most sensible explanation (the only other one was that Schofield was doing something else when Curtis called him back).
    So Dan had to buy out another contract – I’m guessing he heard about that for a while from Lela!
    And I wonder how Frank took it when Dark Shadows was suddenly the hottest thing on TV…

  12. [Spoiler alerts!] From what can be determined from control room conversation at the end of the Matthew Morgan story, during the final episode where he appears as the ghost of Bill Malloy, Frank Schofield’s parting with Dark Shadows turned out to be less than amicable. Frank asked Dan Curtis if there was any further work, and if not then he’d better let him out of his contract because he wasn’t about to sit around waiting another 40 episodes just to be a ghost.

  13. re: 1795 plot – I’m a bit surprised that Frank Schofield didn’t have a part to play in ‘The Past’, as Thayer David (when his character was just killed off) was given a role. Curtis and Swift both liked him so much; and 1795 could always have used another character to get bumped off when things were winding up. Another doomed Collins ancestor? How about a sidekick for the reverend?
    And, of course, it would have been something else for Vicki to freak out about (and scream and scream) when she first saw him.

  14. The Viceroy-smoking skipper seems pensive after his tramp steamer’s last visit to Collinsport. Maybe a premonition about the safety of the girls down by the docks.

  15. It is interesting to speculate on what direction the show might have taken had Roger met his end so early.

    Ghost Roger? The drawing room brandy mysteriously evaporates no matter how much it is refilled…Mrs. Johnson’s boiled dinners are never on time because the stove just won’t stay lit…let’s just pray he manages to keep his dashing looks in the afterlife, I wouldn’t want to see Smushface Roger.

    Vampire Roger! Hmmmm. What a team he and Barnabas would be – Joe and Tom (and Chris, if they’d gone with that) would have been doomed. Well, doom-ed-er. Mind you, it probably wouldn’t be the kind of viewing ABC would like, but who knows? It might’ve been a watershed for the movement.

    But one hopes that Louis Edmonds would have been called back for the 1795 story (if there’d been one); perhaps when Vicki returned to ‘The Present’, she’d changed history and Roger hadn’t died. That would have been fun!
    And what would 1897 have been without Edward? Or indeed any of the other travels in time and dimensions that DS gave us? Thank goodness we need only speculate on such things.

  16. So, we all need to give daily thanks for Roger Collins (and Louis, too). There would have been no DS without him and he’s probably on everybody’s top 5 favorite DS characters list today.
    But – I remember how much I positively loathed Roger when I watched DS as a 10 year old. I would have cheered if Burke had thrown him off Widow’s Hill.

  17. Burke had his private investigator checking around and asking questions 2 weeks in advance of his visit. Also during the phoenix story he lets it be known that he was keeping tabs on Laura’s movements after she was released from the sanitarium.

    However, in his character sketch of Burke Devlin, Art Wallace did write that Devlin’s one overriding goal had become “the complete destruction of the Collins family and what they stand for” (Shadows on the Wall, p. 22). But in the end, what did he actually accomplish? Just [spoiler alert!] the purchase of the Logansport Cannery, a business which had never represented a threat to the Collins family business interests in the past.

    With Roger back at Collinwood, at least Burke can eventually [another spoiler alert!] clear his name and resolve his vendetta. But if Roger had never returned to Collinsport, then no young David in need of a tutor and no need to bring in a governess; Burke is the only passenger stepping off the train that night, and no one else knows he’s even in town, with the exception of Bill Malloy perhaps — but without Roger around, Bill never makes the connection with Sam Evans, so no meeting is called because there’s no “hole” card to play. And without all the tension at Collinwood set in motion by Roger’s pathological fear of Devlin and what he might uncover, Carolyn won’t try and intervene as peacemaker by seeking out Burke and bringing him back to Collinwood; without such a threat to their relationship, Carolyn and Joe eventually get married and live happily ever after — once, of course, that unpleasantness regarding the basement gets resolved with the unexpected return of Jason McGuire.

    Without Roger Collins, the story of Dark Shadows wraps up like Art Wallace’s 1950s teleplay The House — and quietly drops off the air after just 13 weeks.

  18. Was there anything in the DS bible that mentioned how it was that Burke knew that Roger was back in Collinsport, so that he would also return; or did Burke show up and then find about it?

    That guy in the Viceroy ad should really try not to light up so much – I understand that cigarettes might be bad for you.

    Such a lovely moment there as Maggie serves up Sam’s food, putting her arms around his shoulders like that; one of those little touches that gave the character such warmth.

    Would Dan Curtis have had that much to say about what studio space he would be using? That’d be ABC-TV’s call, not DC’s. Especially if the show’s ratings weren’t so good.

    And that Google Maps shot of the studio – pity the poor soul in the middle space out front! Hope he doesn’t have to leave first…that’s some tight parking!

  19. Prisoner – followed along with you as a fellow commentor on DS Everyday. Since I’ve always preferred the pre Barnabas episodes I just wanted to let you know your DS site is fabulous. The level of detail which goes into these posts is awesome. Thanks for your dedication to this frequently overlooked part of DS history.

  20. I’m really enjoying this deep dive into DS. I really love the old commercials. It’s interesting how many products didn’t last and the few that ARE still around 50 years later. I admit I have to look up some of the cigarette brands, because I don’t smoke, so I have no idea what has lasted. Apparently Viceroy is still around.

    I’m also enjoying the hidden audio. I could hear the Lela Swift snippet, even without headphones, but couldn’t hear the one with Dan Curtis and Lela Swift. It’s my old ears. Interesting that she wanted to fire Mitch Ryan, although not due to his drinking. Would a good recast at this early stage have saved the character of Burke Devlin? Mind you I have no idea who would have been a good recast for Ryan, because I loved him as Burke, but it might have avoided the complete miscast of Anthony George later in the series.

Comments are closed.